Thanks to my longtime Parenting editor Robert Barnett for bringing me on board NBC.com's iVillage team, where he is now the top health editor. My first post is on protecting yourself from H1N1 while caring for a sickie at home. Here's the link.
Recently in Other Magazines Category
Thanks to my longtime Parenting editor Robert Barnett for bringing me on board NBC.com's iVillage team, where he is now the top health editor. My first post is on protecting yourself from H1N1 while caring for a sickie at home. Here's the link.


By Jessica Snyder Sachs
1. Work
Out 5 Days a Week?
It's not your
imagination: Our bodies simply become higher maintenance after 40. Indulgences
of food or drink are quicker to take revenge. Muscles require more maintenance.
Screening tests become more important. So there's a lot to remember -- and yet
the wellness precautions keep coming, with new dos and don'ts every passing
year. Can anyone do it all?
Actually,
no. And if you try, say experts, you may end up throwing in the towel on some
of the essentials, as well as what's helpful but optional. So find out where you
can settle for good enough and still enjoy great health.
Rule 1: Work out 30 to 60 minutes a day, five days a week.
The Midlife Shortcut: Catch up
when you miss workouts.
To reduce
the risk of heart disease, cancer, and osteoporosis -- all big concerns for
women over 40 -- experts urge us to exercise at least 30 minutes a day, five
days a week (and for maximum health benefits, make that an hour rather than
half an hour). But daily workouts can be difficult to fit into a life crammed
with work and family responsibilities. Then there's the knee and joint pain
that many women experience after years of pounding their way through
"healthful" exercise.
Why
there's wiggle room: The
cumulative hours -- the total time you clock each week -- is what really counts.
In fact, the weekend warrior has gotten a bad rap, says exercise physiologist
Jane Roy, PhD, of the University of Alabama at Birmingham. If you're too busy
Monday through Friday, weekends are a great time for getting in two or more
hours of enjoyable exercise a day. You can catch up by spending a weekend
morning or afternoon playing tennis with girlfriends, taking back-to-back
aerobic and Pilates classes, or going for a long walk or run.
Then,
during the week, concentrate on interspersing sedentary activities such as
computer work with small but frequent movement breaks, Roy adds.
2. Get a
Pap Smear Yearly?
Rule 2: Get a Pap smear every year.
The Midlife Shortcut: Get tested
every two to three years.
Sexually
active women under 40 should be tested every year, but women over 40 can
stretch it out to once every two to three years once they've had three or more
normal results in a row, as long as they're in a long-term, mutually monogamous
relationship or are not sexually active, and they're still getting annual
pelvic exams.
Why
there's wiggle room: When a
woman is either not having sex or always has it with the same person (and that
person is not having it with anyone else), she's not being exposed to new
strains of the human papillomavirus, explains gynecologist Stacy Tessler
Lindau, MD, of the University of Chicago Medical Center.
The
majority of people who have ever been sexually active have been exposed to one
or more strains of HPV. Most women clear the symptoms of the virus within a few
months. But in a small minority, the infection causes cells to become
precancerous over the course of several years. These are the abnormalities that
show up on Pap tests.
What that
means is the risk of precancerous changes (and ultimately cervical cancer)
becomes very low once women pass through this latency period without being
exposed anew by having sex with someone different. Even if you don't have a new
partner, says Lindau, "You can be exposed to new sexual partners through
your own sexual partner." That's why your relationship has to be mutually
monogamous; if you're not sure it is, continue to be tested every year.
3. Eat 5
Servings of Veggies a Day?
Rule 3: Eat your veggies: five servings a day.
The Midlife Shortcut: Aim to
include veggies in most meals.
Five
servings a day add up to a heck of a lot of vegetables. Using USDA food guide
serving sizes, you'd need to swallow up to 17 cups of salad or solid veggies a
week to meet that goal -- that on top of the four daily servings of fruit
you're supposed to get.
Admittedly,
as the over-40 metabolism slows, substituting produce for higher-calorie foods
and snacks can help with weight control. But as our lives grow exponentially
busier, getting down all those veggies can become overwhelming.
"Five
servings a day remains an admirable goal," says registered dietitian
Christine Gerbstadt, MD, of the American Dietetic Association. And she argues
that meeting it can be a lot easier than you think. "Potatoes count,"
she notes. "Just don't make it french fries every day." You can also
add salsa, tomato sauce, or any kind of bean to the list.
But she's
also willing to compromise. "A decent daily plan is to include some
vegetables in most meals, then concentrate on rounding out the rest of your
diet by pumping up the fibrous whole grains and healthy fats."
Why
there's wiggle room: If you
look at the big nutrition picture and aim for moderate goals, success may
encourage you to surpass your quota. But if you don't hit the mark every single
day, Gerbstadt says, you can get by with a daily multivitamin -- that will
ensure you get the vitamins and minerals that are naturally abundant in fresh
vegetables.
4. Brush
After Every Meal?
Rule 4: Brush after every meal.
The Midlife Shortcut: Put down
the toothbrush and grab some gum.
Or a
toothpick. Or gum. Or a glass of water. It's not necessary to brush your teeth
after every meal if you do something else to remove the food debris.
Why
there's wiggle room: Brushing
when you get up and before you go to bed is just fine, according to Edmond
Hewlett, DDS, of the UCLA School of Dentistry. In fact, Hewlett says it's a bad
idea to brush right after consuming acidic foods or beverages such as wine,
orange juice, and most soft drinks. "The acidity slightly softens tooth
enamel," he explains. So habitually brushing right after eating these
foods can contribute to tooth sensitivity and cavities.
Chewing
sugarless gum has other benefits besides removing food residue. It also
increases saliva, which contains minerals that help replace the enamel lost to
acidic food and acid-producing mouth bacteria. That's particularly important
after age 40, when your natural saliva production starts to decrease. And if
the gum contains xylitol, you'll get an added bonus: This sugar substitute
inhibits the growth of cavity-causing tooth bacteria.
5. Sleep
for 8 Hours?
Rule 5: Eight hours of sleep every night -- no sleeping in.
The Midlife Shortcut: Sleep late
on weekends.
Yes, the
human body does need eight hours of sound sleep each night, says Joanne Getsy,
MD, of Drexel University College of Medicine, in Philadelphia. "It's a
fallacy that you need less sleep as you get older," she says. "You
don't need less; you simply get less." Anyone dealing with hot flashes and
sleep disturbances knows this too well. But whereas many experts insist that
"catch-up sleep" isn't as good as the real thing, Getsy says there's
room for deviating from your normal wakeup and going-to-bed times.
Why
there's wiggle room: "The
aim should be to pay back your sleep debt as soon as you can," Getsy says.
Specifically, she recommends scheduling twice-a-week catch-up nights.
"Pick one weeknight and one weekend night, and don't plan anything on
those evenings," she advises. "Let them be your nights to
recover." Daytime napping is okay too, she adds: "Just keep it under
an hour so it doesn't interfere with a solid night's sleep."
As for
sleep-bingeing on weekends, Getsy advises staying in bed as late as you like on
Saturday. Then on Sunday, split the difference between when you'd like to get
up and when you have to get up on Monday. That will help ease you back into
your weekday schedule.
Even
better news: Getsy says that when it comes to sleep debt, it's okay to pay back
less than you borrowed. Usually one full night's sleep is enough to make up for
a couple of shortchanged ones, she says. "If you feel better in the
morning, you've slept enough."
6. Lift
Weights 3 Times a Week?
Rule 6: Lift weights three times a week.
The Midlife Shortcut: Try for
one or two sessions a week.
On top of
encouraging us to meet aerobic exercise quotas, the health gurus tell us to get
to the gym and pump iron at least three days a week. Strength training is
especially important after menopause, at which point a woman's body tends to
lose both muscle mass and bone strength.
"When
you make the muscle grow, you strengthen the bone that's attached to it,"
explains Felicia Cosman, MD, of the National Osteoporosis Foundation. Aerobic
exercise such as jogging works only about 20 percent of muscle fibers, she
says, while strength training with weights engages up to 90 percent.
Why
there's wiggle room: There's no
magic number as to how often you need to strength train. Aim for regularity,
Cosman says, even if it's just twice a week. Nor do you have to schlep to a
gym. "Weight machines and free weights are good," Cosman says,
"but so are equipment-free Pilates and yoga moves, and push-ups."
7. Do a
Breast Self-Exam?
Rule 7: Do a breast self-exam every month.
The Midlife Shortcut: Do it
often enough to notice changes.
We came of
age being trained to search for lumps every month. The mandate feels even more
compelling now, given how greatly the incidence of breast cancer increases
after 40.
As it
turns out, however, there's little evidence that obsessively examining yourself
really helps women catch more life-threatening lumps.
Why
there's wiggle room: After
years of urging women to perform monthly self-exams, the American Cancer
Society recently deemed them optional. But what's still important, says ACS
spokesperson Debbie Saslow, PhD, is that women become familiar with how their
breasts feel and what's normal for them. "For a lot of women, that's still
a monthly exam. For others, it's the occasional self-exam or simply paying
attention when getting dressed or showering."
Where Not
to Cheat
Here's
where our health gurus draw the line. Follow these three rules, they say, as
scrupulously as you can.
Keep
Moving
Yes, you get brownie points for working out on weekends, but you lose out on
lots of benefits if you just sit in a chair the rest of the week, says Jane
Roy, PhD, of the University of Alabama at Birmingham. So get up for a stretch
break at least once an hour at work (you could walk down the hall to talk to a
colleague instead of sending an e-mail), and a few times a day, catch some
fresh air with a quick five-minute stroll outside.
If you
need extra motivation, consider this: Five one-minute stretch breaks over the
course of a day burn just 15 to 20 calories. But over the course of a year,
that adds up to over two pounds of fat.
Get a
Mammogram Every Year
When cancer strikes women in their 40s, the tumors tend to be aggressive, which
means fast-growing -- so the early detection offered by mammograms is crucial,
says the American Cancer Society's Debbie Saslow. After menopause, women tend
to have slower-growing cancers, she adds, but the incidence increases. "So
going longer than a year just isn't worth the risk," she says.
Maintain a
Healthy Weight
Overweight women are more likely to develop heart disease, diabetes, and many
types of cancer than normal-weight women are.
In fact, a
recent analysis estimates that 20 percent of all cancer deaths in American
women are linked to excess weight. In general, cancer rates increase when a
woman's body mass index exceeds 25, says Colleen Doyle of the American Cancer
Society. The risk rises more dramatically when the BMI passes 30. Abdominal fat
appears to be closely associated with postmenopausal breast cancer and cancers
of the colon and pancreas. And some experts say that the risk increases when a
woman's waistline exceeds 32 inches.
Originally
published in MORE magazine, February 2009.

Antibiotic-resistant
germs are showing up in hospitals, playrooms, and gyms around the country.
Here's how to keep you and your family safe
By Jessica
Snyder Sachs, as first appeared in PREVENTION
magazine
One summer
morning in 2004, Susanne Petrosky, 37, of Perkasie, PA, woke up feeling
feverish. It was a month after she'd given birth to her third child, and one
touch of her left breast--hot, swollen, tender--told her it was infected. She
knew the drill, having been through it with her second baby. She called her
doctor, picked up a prescription for the antibiotic clindamycin, and took it faithfully for the full 7 days. No
more breast infection.
Then the
diarrhea started, with cramping so bad it made her recent labor pains seem
mild. She made an appointment to see her doctor and got on the Internet.
"I typed in clindamycin and side effects and it came
right up--severe, sometimes fatal, diarrhea," she says. On the phone, her
doctor was reassuring. That was on a Thursday. She spent much of the weekend
lying on the bathroom floor; on Monday morning her sister drove her to the
doctor. "He took one look at me," Petrosky says, "and told us to
go straight to the emergency room."
Petrosky had
picked up a dangerous new strain of an old bug: Clostridium difficile. The
bacteria, which produces toxins in the intestine, is common--when people on antibiotics end up with diarrhea, C.
difficile is often to blame. Generally, once they've finished taking the drugs,
the diarrhea clears up on its own. But the new strain is much nastier than
normal. It churns out 20 times the colon-damaging toxins as the older version,
causing severe intestinal inflammation, or colitis, and is resistant to several
important antibiotics. When Petrosky got sick,
Canadian hospitals had already reported more than 200 deaths from C.
difficile--toxins had eaten right through the walls of patients' colons. Many
American hospitals were experiencing similar outbreaks, and the hypervirulent
strain had begun to infect people in the general community. Since then, the
situation has only gotten worse.
Experts have
long warned against the overuse of antibiotics because of the possibility
that bacteria would develop resistance to the drugs we use to kill them. Now,
researchers say, some of their fears have come to pass. The CDC estimates that
of the approximately 2 million bacterial infections Americans acquire in
hospitals each year, 70% are resistant to at least one of the drugs commonly
used against them. Why that's scaring the experts: If standard drugs don't
work, doctors sometimes have to turn to more potent--and more
toxic--alternatives. In some cases, those last-resort antibiotics have caused irreversible liver
or kidney problems or lasting pain from nerve damage. In others, people
have died for lack of an effective treatment. The CDC says that drug resistance
kills 70,000 Americans each year--more than car accidents and homicides
combined.
"The
superbugs are here," says Martin J. Blaser, MD, president of the
Infectious Diseases Society of America and the chair of New York University
Medical School's department of medicine. "And it doesn't take a crystal
ball to see that even more problems are coming."
Scientists
are trying to develop new bacteria-fighting drugs, but that process takes
decades. In the meantime, we have to defend ourselves. It's crucial to be able
to recognize the warning signs of a superbug infection, or, even better,
prevent one. Here are four of the most dangerous of these germs and how leading
experts say you can protect yourself.
Superbug C.
difficile: A Toxic Intestinal Bug
When Petrosky
got to the hospital, doctors immediately put her on extrapowerful antibiotics. She improved, but her right
arm went numb from medicine-induced nerve damage; when her physicians switched
drugs, she relapsed. It took more than 9 weeks to get her out of danger. After
her recovery, her 4-year-old son and a neighbor went through similar bouts of
illness. The neighbor had to be hospitalized.
The number of
new cases of C. difficile-associated colitis among US hospital patients has
doubled over the past 5 to 10 years, to as many as 500,000 a year, reports CDC
medical epidemiologist L. Clifford McDonald, MD. The infection rate outside
hospitals appears to have increased many times over, as well. And the death
rate has skyrocketed: from less than 2% to as high as 17%.
Prevent It
Don't badger
your doctor for unnecessary antibiotics. Remember: Antibiotics don't work against viral
infections such as colds or flus.
Ask about
alternatives if your doctor suggests long-term antibiotics for a chronic bacterial
infection such as acne. (Try remedies like benzoyl peroxide cream instead.)
Avoid
broad-spectrum antibiotics, if possible, when an illness
requires an antibiotic. (Broad spectrum means they kill off good bacteria along
with the bad.) The broad-spectrum antibiotics most associated with C. difficile
infection are clindamycin (Cleocin), and the
fluoroquinolones (Cipro, Floxin, and Levaquin).
Consider
upping your intake of "friendly" bacteria, such as Lactobacillus and
Bifidobacterium. They can be found in many brands of live-culture yogurt. Such
a step can't hurt; research continues on whether it can help deny bad bugs a
foothold in your system.
Treat It
Contact your
doctor if you have diarrhea or cramping and gas that lasts longer than a few
days, and avoid antidiarrheal remedies, which can prevent your body from
expelling C. difficile's tissue-damaging toxins. Instead, drink lots of fluids
to stay hydrated and try the BRAT diet: bananas, rice, applesauce, and toast.
Superbug
MRSA: Out of the Hospital and in your Community
On Christmas
night, 2005, 14-month-old Bryce Smith had a stuffy nose and slight fever--his
first cold, say his parents, Katie and Scott Smith of Santee, CA. Around
midnight on New Year's Eve, Bryce began to struggle frighteningly for breath.
The Smiths rushed him to the hospital, where a nurse checked his oxygen level.
Within seconds, Katie recalls, at least 10 doctors and nurses had crowded
around her baby, looking very scared.
X-rays and CT
scans showed that Bryce's lungs were riddled with holes, and a team of surgeons
hurried him into the operating room. Doctors told the Smiths that Bryce had the
worst kind of lung infection, one caused by a particularly virulent variety of
staph bacteria. Dubbed CA-MRSA, for community-acquired methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus,
the bacteria is resistant to penicillin, amoxicillin, and the other
"cillins." And it produces poisons--which were chewing up Bryce's
lungs.
Bryce lay in
a medically induced coma for a month as doctors infused his body with a
cocktail of antibiotics, sedatives, and other drugs.
The medicines worked: After 40 days, the doctors brought him out of sedation
and removed his tubes. But his parents have to be supervigilant now, because
the treatment weakened his immune system, at least temporarily. "What
would be an ordinary cold for us could prove deadly for him," his dad
says.
Staph causes
problems only when it slips past the body's defenses, through a cut or scratch
or into lungs weakened by a viral infection. Close contact--on playing fields,
in locker rooms and showers, and between children in day care and
preschool--has been the key to many outbreaks. (Young children appear to be
particularly at risk.)
MRSA made
headlines in 2005 when Miami Dolphins Junior Seau and Charles Rodgers were
hospitalized with limb-threatening skin infections and college football player
Ricky Lannetti of Philadelphia died suddenly of MRSA pneumonia on the heels of
the flu. And a study in the New England Journal of Medicine startled physicians
by revealing that the bug now causes more than half of all skin infections
treated in US emergency rooms. It's crucial, say researchers, for doctors to
keep the possibility of MRSA in mind--the study found that most cases of
MRSA were treated with drugs that don't work against the superbug.
How To Avoid
MRSA
Prevent It
* Wash cuts and scrapes thoroughly with soap
and water.
* Don't share personal items such as towels and
razors, and just in case you have a scratch that would offer entry to MRSA,
always keep your clothing or a towel between your skin and any shared surfaces
such as workout equipment or locker-room benches. *
* Get vaccinated against the flu--the disease
clearly raises the risk of the most severe kind of staph infections.
Treat It
* Don't ignore an infected wound or a
pus-filled boil--not even a scratch, if it seems to worsen over the course of a
few days. MRSA skin infections tend to be very red, swollen, and painful,
sometimes with a raised bump resembling a spider bite. Getting the right
antibiotic is critical, so ask your doctor to consider the possibility of MRSA.
* Be particularly vigilant about any chest cold
or flu that takes a sudden turn for the worse, or a fever that spikes over 102
degrees F. "Every major medical center is now on the alert for MRSA,"
says John Bradley, MD, chief of infectious disease at Rady Children's
Hospital--San Diego, where Bryce was treated. "But there's still a problem
with general practitioners and small community hospitals, where doctors may
never have seen a case."
Superbug E.
Coli: Food's Dangerous Hitchhiker
Frightening
news stories recently about the damage done by tainted spinach made it horrifyingly clear:
Produce, like meat, can harbor lethal germs. The culprit in spinach, E. coli 0157:H7, is not antibiotic resistant (in fact, antibiotics are not used to treat this
infection), but is indisputably extratoxic; the poisons it produces can cause
fatal kidney failure. Strains of other foodborne bugs, Salmonella and Campylobacter, turn out vicious toxins, as
well--and these bugs shrug off many drugs that once could vanquish them. All
told, these pathogens sicken 3 to 4 million Americans each year and kill
several hundred.
Prevent It
Be scrupulous
about washing hands after touching raw meat or eggs, and cook these foods
thoroughly. (More than half of all cuts of raw supermarket chicken carry Salmonella and
Campylobacter, studies show.)
Use hot,
soapy water to wash cutting boards and other kitchen surfaces that come in
contact with raw meat or eggs.
Rinse
produce--even veggies and fruits with a thick rind, such as cantaloupe--with a
strong spray of water. If produce is contaminated by irrigation water, as was
the case with spinach, only thorough cooking will
destroy the germs.
Wash your
(and your kids') hands after handling pet rodents and reptiles or farm animals,
which can spread Salmonella and Campylobacter.
Throw your
kitchen sponges into the dishwasher daily and dishrags into the washing machine
often; use hot water.
Treat It
Superbug UTI:
Bladder Infections That Won't Quit
The first
time Dena Kelley got a urinary tract infection, she ended up in the emergency room.
It was the winter of 1999, and Kelley, now a 33-year-old store manager in
Anchorage, was seeing what looked like tissue in the toilet bowl--the lining of
her infected bladder. "It was unbelievably painful," she says,
"and it scared the heck out of me."
The ER doc
gave Kelley a powerful antibiotic--Cipro--to stop the infection fast, but 6
weeks later, Kelley got another UTI. Over the next year, she averaged an infection every 2
months. Finally, her doctors reluctantly turned to a drug to which she'd been
allergic in childhood--amoxicillin, at four times the usual dose. Fortunately,
Kelley had outgrown her sensitivity to the drug, which ended the agonizing
bouts of UTIs. But she can no longer make it through the night without a trip
to the bathroom. And her doctors have told her that permanent bladder damage
may predispose her to chronic infections throughout her life.
Roughly half
of all women get at least one UTI at some point in their lives. Until the late
1990s, doctors were able to treat the problem with trimethoprim-sulfamethoxazole (Bactrim), a narrowly
targeted antibiotic with minimal side effects. But many UTIs have become
resistant to Bactrim and other drugs. So doctors must use stronger antibiotics that can cause problems of
their own.
"It's
frustrating," says Gazala Siddiqui, MD, a urogynecologist at the
University of Texas Medical School at Austin. "These powerful antibiotics increase the chances of a yeast infection, and also the chances that
a woman's next bacterial infection--whether it's another UTI or pneumonia--will
be drug resistant."
If a
resistant UTI lingers, it can cause scarring--which predisposes a woman to even
more UTIs. Some doctors try to stop the vicious cycle by keeping women on antibiotics for months at a time. But that
virtually guarantees that any break-through infections will be impervious to antibiotics, says Siddiqui, who's
sometimes had to admit patients to the hospital for intravenous treatment.
Prevent
Antibiotic-Resistant Bladder Infections
Prevent It
Begin with
good vaginal hygiene: Wipe from front to back after using the toilet and pee
before and after sexual intercourse. Don't douche, and consider alternatives to
spermicides; both can irritate the delicate tissue around the urethra, raising
the odds of infection.
Discourage
UTI-causing bacteria by making the urinary tract and vagina more acidic. "Cranberry juice is good at this. Cranberry capsules are better," says
Siddiqui, who recommends two or three glasses or capsules a day for women who
are prone to recurrent infection. Also helpful: acidifying vaginal jelly
available by prescription (Acigel) or over the counter (RepHresh).
Try a low-estrogen vaginal cream if you're peri- or
postmenopausal and getting lots of UTIs. It will keep the tissue of the urethra
from thinning and becoming more vulnerable to infection.
Treat It
If you
suspect a UTI, ask your doc to send a urine sample for analysis. Start antibiotics, but call back for results. If
it turns out not to be a bacterial infection, stop the drugs and work with your
doc to find the true cause. If a bacteria is at fault, check to make sure the
drug you're on is effective against the bug you have.
3 Stay-Healthy
Moves To Make Right Now
1. Scrubbing
with old-fashioned soap and hot water is the best way to keep germs at
bay. Do it before eating, after using the toilet or handling animals, and
before and after preparing food. Wash vigorously for 20 seconds, experts
say--about the time it takes to sing "Yankee Doodle Dandy."
2. If a sink
isn't handy, clean up with an alcohol hand sanitizer. Studies show that
when someone is sick in a household, classroom, or workplace, using a gel
(between hand washings) reduces the spread of disease-causing bacteria and
viruses. Be sure to choose a product containing 60 to 95% alcohol--some contain less and can
actually help spread germs. Use a generous gob--enough so that hands still feel
damp after rubbing them together for 20 seconds.
3. Skip
antibacterial soap. Household
soaps and other products with antibacterial chemicals, such as triclosan and
triclocarban, don't prevent infection any better than products without them,
studies show. Worse, some experts worry that they may promote drug resistance.
There's no proof yet that they do, admits resistance crusader Stuart B. Levy,
MD, of Tufts University. "But why take the risk when they haven't been
shown to be any more effective?"
Have A
Healthy Hospital Stay
Ironically,
"A hospital is not a good place to be when you're sick," says Curtis
Donskey, MD, chief of infection control at the Cleveland VA Medical Center.
Filled with the sickest patients on the strongest antibiotics, they're breeding grounds for
superbugs. Unfortunately, many doctors neglect the steps that can reduce
patients' risk of picking up nasty germs during their stay, says Donskey, who
has spent a decade raising awareness among his colleagues. Enlist a friend or
family member to help ensure that doctors and other medical personnel follow
these guidelines.
* Ask your
doctor to remove invasive devices such as catheters and IV lines as soon as
it's safe--they provide a pathway into your body for dangerous bacteria.
* Request the
most highly targeted antibiotic if you require one. Remind your doctor to take
you off the drug as soon as possible.
* Demand to
know more about infection rates. Few states now require hospitals to release
this information, so it's next to impossible to "shop around" to
avoid particularly risky facilities. That may be changing: New York recently
passed a law requiring hospitals to make public their rates of
hospital-acquired infection, and a number of other states are considering
similar legislation.
Writer Jessica Snyder Sachs is the author of Good
Germs, Bad Germs: Health & Survival in a Bacterial World
(Hill&Wang/FSG) and Corpse: Nature, Forensics, and the Struggle to Pinpoint
Time of Death (Perseus/Basic Books).

Hospitals need to come clean about infections and what's causing them.
copyright Jessica Snyder Sachs, as originally appeared in The [Newark] Star-Ledger
Our neighborhoods are in a panic over news reports about MRSA, or methicillin resistant Staphylococcus aureus. There's no doubt that this nasty bug has moved into our communities and our schools. But the deadliest threat from MRSA--and an alphabet soup of other drug-resistant bacteria--remain behind the doors of our local hospitals. Eight-five percent of MRSA infections occur during or following a stay in a healthcare facility.
The sad truth is that our hospitals have become dangerous places to be sick. Even routine surgical procedures bring the risk of potentially deadly infections involving hospital-bred bacteria. Infections picked up in health-care settings kill an estimated 99,000 Americans each year, more than twice as many as die in car crashes. It's a problem that has grown dramatically worse by the decade, as our antibiotic-infused medical centers became breeding grounds for drug-resistant bacteria.
In addition to MRSA, other increasingly common hospital superbugs include a viciously toxic strain of Clostridium difficile, bred from the bacterium that commonly causes post-antibiotic diarrhea; vancomycin resistant enterococcus (VRE), a virtually untreatable bug bred from a harmless member of our intestinal microflora; and Actinobacter baumannii, another near-unstoppable microbe, this one recently introduced into our hospitals in the infected wounds of soldiers returning from Iraq, Afghanistan, and before that, Kuwait.
The good news is that a half century of dangerous secrecy is starting to come to an end. This year New Jersey joined New York and Connecticut in the ranks of at least 22 states with some sort of mandate for the reporting of hospitals infections. These laws represent a step in the right direction. But few ask hospitals to differentiate infections caused by "ordinary" bacteria and those caused by highly drug resistant superbugs. New Jersey is one of these exceptions, with a new law on the books requiring specific reporting of hospital MRSA.
The importance of such reporting laws goes beyond a consumer's desire to steer clear of a medical center plagued with abysmal infection control. Worse, fifty years of secrecy have left public health officials guessing as to the arrival and spread of deadly new strains of drug-resistant bacteria in our hospitals.
The current situation with C. difficile illustrates the problem. Since 2003, C. difficile deaths have dominated news in Canada and the United Kingdom. British tabloid headlines like "Toe Nail Surgery Nearly Killed Me" refer to the common scenario wherein someone checks into the hospital for a routine procedure, receives antibiotics, and promptly contracts this drug-resistant invader.
Public outcry in Canada and the UK produced tremendous political pressure to address the problem in those countries. Even today, British lawmakers are quick to call the government's health minister before Parliament for public castigation when quarterly hospital reports of either MRSA or C. difficile rates fail to show improvement.
Ironically, in 2005, medical detectives traced the origins of the toxic C. difficile strain wreaking havoc in Canada and the U.K. to the United States, where hospitals had been heedlessly experiencing deadly outbreaks for at least six years. "We had no idea what was going on," admitted the chief of infection control at the University of Pittsburgh Medical Center, which in 2005 belatedly reported that its own C. difficile death toll had begun a dramatic ascent in January 2000.
Once forced to examine and deal with their superbug problems, hospitals can make great strides. This month, a once-chastened University of Pittsburgh Medical Center reported that it has brought its C. difficile rates down by more than 70 percent with an aggressive combination of tactics that include requiring doctors to get permission from an antimicrobial management team before prescribing the kind of powerful antibiotics known to raze the body's good bacteria and, so, leave a patient vulnerable to C. difficile and other drug-resistant bacteria.
Once their dirty secrets are out, other medical centers can likewise begin sharing and comparing infection control efforts. To that end, the first round state laws requiring hospitals to report infections in a general way do not go far enough. Our state legislators need to ride the current wave of public concern about supergerms to pass further legislation requiring hospitals to report on infection problems on a bug by bug basis--starting with their most dangerous and drug-resistant bacteria.
Jessica Snyder Sachs, a contributing editor to Popular Science and Parenting magazines, is the author of Good Germs, Bad Germs: Health and Survival in a Bacterial World.
[JUMP BACK TO HOME PAGE]
Many of us are in the danger zone, and we don't realize it. What to do right now.by Jessica Snyder Sachs, as first appeared in HEALTH magazine
How's your cholesterol? Here's a guess: If you're healthy, you probably have no idea. New surveys show women tend to be clueless about their risks of heart disease, especially when it comes to managing their cholesterol.
But this kind of ignorance is anything but bliss. The reason: The
artery clogging that makes heart disease the number-one killer of women
late in life begins much earlier--in your 20s, 30s, and 40s--and that's
when your cholesterol numbers may be sounding alarms. So, are you ready
to start paying attention? Here, the things all women need to know now.
1. High cholesterol is surprisingly common in premenopausal women.
Researchers with the Framingham Heart Study recently delivered a nasty
surprise: Nearly a quarter of women in the study who are in their early
30s have borderline-high levels of bad cholesterol, as do more than a
third in their early 40s and more than half in their early 50s. A third
of women in all three age groups have low levels of good cholesterol.
Bad cholesterol, also known as low-density lipoprotein (LDL), contributes to heart disease by laying down artery-clogging plaque; good cholesterol, or high-density lipoprotein (HDL), helps clear it away. "The double whammy of high LDL and low HDL is particularly dangerous," says Framingham researcher Vasan Ramachandran, MD, of the Boston University School of Medicine.
2. Your doctor may miss the problem.
Though women are better than men about seeing a doctor regularly, the
care they receive isn't as good when it comes to preventing and
treating cardiovascular disease, according to new studies. "Perhaps
doctors still haven't gotten the message that women need to control
cholesterol," says Chloe Bird, PhD, author of one of these studies and
a senior sociologist at the nonprofit RAND Corporation. Bird found that
doctors are less likely to monitor and control cholesterol in women
than in men, even when the women are at superhigh risk of heart attack.
Part of the problem, she says, may be that many women see only a gynecologist. This isn't to say that OB-GYNs can't be good primary care doctors, but you have to make sure the doc is willing to monitor your heart health, especially if you already have diabetes or a heart issue. That means she should order cholesterol checks as part of your regular blood work and discuss the results with you. What does "regular" mean? See "How Often Do I Need a Checkup?"
3. Your numbers may trick you.
Many people misunderstand the roles of so-called good and bad
cholesterols, according to cardiologist and lipidologist Pamela Morris,
MD, of the Medical University of South Carolina in Charleston. "What
we've learned is that HDL and LDL are independent predictors of a
woman's heart attack risk," she explains. "We see women with high HDLs
having heart attacks when their LDL is also high, and we also see heart
attacks in women with very low LDL but also low HDL."
What that means to you: It's important to keep track of both. A woman wants to keep her HDL above 60 (the level at which HDL helps prevent disease) and her LDL below 100. If your HDL drops below 50 or LDL rises above 160, you need to take immediate action. That may include an LDL-lowering drug such as a statin, and it definitely includes a commitment to a heart-healthy diet and lifestyle.
4. You may need an "inflammation" test.
The math used to estimate your heart disease risk is a little
misleading. If your LDL rises above the danger line of 160 or your HDL
drops below 50, the math says you have an elevated risk of a heart
attack within 10 years. But that warning may actually underestimate
your risks beyond 10 years, Morris says. So when she has a female
patient with cholesterol numbers in the intermediate range--LDL above
130 or HDL under 60--she often takes a close look at the woman's
whole-body inflammation level.
You can't see this kind of inflammation, but it's actually an independent measure of heart attack risk. You measure it by adding a test for high-sensitivity C-reactive protein (hs-CRP) to the usual cholesterol blood work. CRP, essentially a body chemical, usually rises anytime your body becomes inflamed. And since artery clogging is associated with inflammation, high CRP is viewed as a marker for clogged arteries. That means your C-reactive protein levels may help you and your doctor decide how aggressively you need to control borderline-high-cholesterol levels with drugs, diet, and exercise.
5. These foods are your best friends.
Certain classes of food chemicals can actively and powerfully lower a
person's bad cholesterol. Two--soluble fiber and phytosterols--have so
much science behind them that they've become part of standard medical
prescriptions for treating high cholesterol. But dietitian Janet Brill,
PhD, RD, author of Cholesterol Down, also recommends regularly eating
almonds, ground flaxseed, apples, soy protein, and olive oil.
Preliminary research suggests they all have cholesterol-lowering
powers. "Each one works in a slightly different way," Brill says. "So
together, you get a synergy that can dramatically lower cholesterol."
Almonds and olive oil are high in monounsaturated fats, which are thought to blend with LDL molecules in a way that speeds LDL's clearance from the blood by the liver. Flax is high in both soluble fiber, which lowers LDL by absorbing cholesterol from both food and bile inside the intestines, and omega-3 fatty acids, which studies show have anti-inflammatory effects. Other foods especially high in soluble fiber include oat bran, oatmeal, and apples. (Soluble fiber is different from insoluble fiber, the kind found in whole-grain bread and bran cereal. That's good for you, too, but it won't affect your cholesterol.) Soy may mimic natural estrogens in their LDL-clearing effects. Phytosterols are the plant version of animal sterols (a.k.a. cholesterol) and lower LDL by competing with it for absorption into the body. They're found in supplements or phytosterol-enhanced margarine such as Benecol.
You don't need any of these foods if your LDL is low, but experts still recommend them for everyone. What about steak, eggs, and cheese? They sure won't help your cholesterol, because they all contain a lot of it. But it's more important to focus on foods that lower your numbers rather than simply avoiding the bad stuff, experts say.
6. Good cholesterol may have a bad side.
The higher your HDL, the better, right? That's been the current
thinking, due to HDL's protective effect. But here's a surprise you may
have read about in some news reports: Studies are showing that HDL may
actually have harmful proteins capable of boosting heart disease risks.
A test to determine if your HDL has the harmful proteins may be
available in a few years. In the meantime, if your HDL is lower than
60, it's still OK to raise it a little as long as you don't go
overboard. How? Try getting a lot of omega-3s from fish or fish oil,
exercising regularly, controlling your weight, and avoiding smoking.
7. Your heart loves long walks.
Walking 10 miles a week brings lasting improvements in your heart
health, according to researchers at Duke University Medical Center. The
funny thing is, if you jog those 10 miles, you won't get quite as much
benefit. "Duration appears to be key," says Duke's Cris Slentz, PhD, an
exercise physiologist. "Jogging or walking 10 miles both burned around
1,200 calories, but in our studies, one took about two hours and the
other, three."
Longer stints of exercise, even moderate exercise, may burn more belly fat--the little rolls of skin near your navel and the fat deep inside your abdomen. The latter is linked to metabolic syndrome, a condition associated with a host of cardiovascular risk factors including low HDL, high blood pressure, and high triglycerides (a kind of blood fat that contributes to heart disease).
Should you aim for weight loss as well as long walks? If you're
overweight, absolutely. But understand that shedding a few pounds will
make only a small dent in your cholesterol. Canadian researchers
recently found that overweight women who lost about 25 pounds--no easy
task--saw their LDL drop about 10 percent and their HDL rise by the same
amount.
How Often Do I Need a Checkup?
Starting at age 19 and continuing until menopause, a cholesterol test
once every five years is plenty--as long as your numbers fall in the
healthy range:
HDL > 60
LDL < 100
Total cholesterol (HDL plus LDL) < 200.
But any time your numbers stray into unhealthy territory (and during and after menopause, when heart disease risk rises), get tested annually and work out an action plan with your doctor.
Writer Jessica Snyder Sachs is the author of Good Germs, Bad Germs, out in paperback this fall.[RETURN TO MAIN PAGE]
MRSA infects 94,000 Americans a year, and the superbug is no longer confined to hospitals. Here's what you need to know to protect yourself and your kids.copyright Jessica Snyder Sachs, as first appeared in BEST LIFE magazine
It started one morning last June, when 14-year-old Max Yardley felt a little tenderness in his elbow. The arm looked fine, so Max's dad, Rockie, an explosives specialist with the Edmond, Oklahoma, police department, figured the problem was soreness left over from the lifeguard training Max had just completed. But that night, Max woke up his parents at 3 a.m. The pain had become excruciating.
"This is a kid who doesn't normally complain," says Yardley. "He'd been sick all of five days in his life." The Yardleys raced to the emergency room. Over the next 24 hours, Max's temperature soared to triple digits and his blood pressure plummeted. When doctors ran the usual laboratory tests, it came back positive for methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus, or MRSA. A bacterial infection had infected the bone of Max's upper arm and was racing through his body, shredding up his lungs, liver, and spleen.
"One morning we had a perfectly healthy boy. Twenty-four hours later, the doctors were struggling to keep him alive long enough for the antibiotics to start working," recalls Yardley, who, as a former paramedic, understood enough about his son's vital signs to call the family's priest.
Unknown just 15 years ago, community MRSA (hospital MRSA's virulent sister) now accounts for more than half the serious staph infections showing up in the nation's emergency rooms. Some children's hospitals see it in more than 75 percent of the staph-infected children they treat.
"Once it arrives in a community, it just seems to take over," says Sheldon Kaplan, MD, chief of infectious diseases at Texas Children's Hospital, in Houston. Pediatric specialists fear that the superbug, which already accounts for 19,000 deaths in the United States each year, could soon become commonplace across the country. The vast majority of community MRSA cases are skin and soft-tissue infections, Dr. Kaplan explains.
But around 5 percent involve potentially deadly pneumonias and internal infections such as Max's. When this bug enters the bloodstream, it can cause severe and sometimes fatal disease, and many of those who survive bloodstream infections sustain severe organ damage, require limb amputation, or both. "A child's growing bones remain particularly vulnerable," says Dr. Kaplan, "because they are open to bacteria circulating in the bloodstream."
Max was one of the lucky ones. After a week on a respirator, he emerged without permanent organ damage. After another two weeks on intravenous antibiotics, he finally went home to complete his recovery and was symptom free after another seven weeks on antibiotics.
Each year, more and more kids aren't so fortunate. MRSA deaths among previously healthy kids began cropping up in the 1990s. "At first we assumed these children had some connection to a health-care setting in which MRSA infections had been confined," explains epidemiologist Jeffrey Hageman, a MRSA expert with the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, "but it eventually became clear that something else was going on." Antibiotic use outside of hospitals may have bred strains of MRSA distinct from those in medical centers.
And although community MRSA isn't resistant to as many kinds of antibiotics as is hospital MRSA, what it lacks in multidrug resistance it appears to make up for in virulence. Medical experts are just working out how staph in general, and MRSA in particular, wreaks its damage. But new studies suggest that community MRSA strains have the ability to kill the kinds of immune cells that would normally eliminate such microbial invaders. This stubborn persistence, in turn, tends to trigger septic shock, a kind of immune-system meltdown in which body-wide inflammation leads to organ failure, massive blood clotting, and plummeting blood pressure.
Community MRSA has an aggressive tendency to enter through even the smallest of cuts and abrasions. For this reason, it often spreads in locker rooms and gyms, and between members of sports and dance teams, who have frequent skin contact with both other participants' skin and shared surfaces such as athletic equipment and benches, explains Hageman.
Ineed, if you have a child in school or day care, chances are you've received some version of the panic-but-don't-panic note, as in "Dear parents: A confirmed case of MRSA infection has been brought to our attention. Please be assured we are taking appropriate measures." Some schools go so far as to shut their doors for a massive, one-time disinfection--a move that may be as ineffectual as it is overdramatic.
A less overblown but diligent effort is key, say health experts. "Perhaps one of the biggest problems for parents, dads in particular, is deciding when to give your kid Tylenol and send him to bed and when to go straight to the emergency room," says Yardley. "For me, it was the urgency of Max's complaints that raised the red flag."
Here's what you need to know to protect your children from community MRSA:
1. Know When Risk is Greatest
Studies show some of the highest rates of MRSA in groups such as team athletes and those who have had a medical procedure or taken antibiotics within the past year. MRSA is what doctors call an "opportunistic pathogen," a microbe that takes advantage of breaches in the body's defenses. Young children are particularly susceptible because their immune systems aren't yet fully developed. "Staph. aureus can't be eradicated," explains MRSA expert Jeffrey Hageman, of the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. "Overall, around one in a hundred Americans carries a resistant strain of this bug."
2. Avoid Unnecessary Antibiotics
MRSA infection rates are up to eight times higher among those who've taken antibiotics in the previous year. By eliminating the drug-susceptible competition, antibiotics promote the success of any microbe that can shrug off their effects. "Antibiotics tend to replace your body's protective bacteria with drug-resistant troublemakers," explains Tufts University's Stuart Levy, MD, author of The Antibiotic Paradox. When antibiotics are necessary, ask your doctor for the "narrowest spectrum" (most specifically targeted) antibiotics, which tend to be less disruptive of the body's good bacteria than are "broad spectrum" (big gun) antibiotics.
3. Wash Away the Bugs
"Teaching children good hygiene is the single most important thing you can do to protect them," says Hageman. Staph spreads primarily through skin-to-skin contact and frequently touched surfaces. Experts recommend frequent hand-washing with ordinary soap and water or, when that's not convenient, an alcohol-based hand gel. "Staph takes several hours to infect an abrasion," says Hageman, "so there's a window of time when it can be washed from the skin."
Drug-resistance experts such as Levy advise against using antibacterial soaps containing chemicals such as triclocarban and triclosan. They act like antibiotics and, in laboratory tests, promote the rise of drug-resistant bacteria.
4. Keep Exercise Areas Clean Encourage young athletes--or their coaches--to wipe down mats and sporting equipment with soap and water or bleach wipes between uses. Children can also use a personal towel or other barrier between their skin and shared exercise surfaces and equipment. Insist on daily disinfection of locker rooms and weight-room benches, wrestling mats, and other shared athletic equipment as well as the mats used by younger children for napping. The Environmental Protection Agency maintains a list of safe and effective MRSA disinfectants.
5. When in Doubt, Check It Out
MRSA infections don't always look scary. The skin may become red, swollen, and tender. An infected joint, bone, or muscle may look normal but feel painful. Sometimes symptoms include fever, nausea, or weakness, says Sheldon Kaplan, MD, of Texas Children's Hospital. That can make MRSA infection difficult to distinguish from muscle sprains or the flu.
6. Get a Flu Shot
When MRSA and the flu end up in the same body, the result can be life-threatening. "It's the perfect storm," says John Francis, MD, an infectious disease consultant at Yale University School of Medicine. Getting an annual flu shot may help protect against this deadly combination.
Jessica Snyder Sachs is the author of Good Germs, Bad Germs, out in paperback this fall.
[BACK TO HOME PAGE]
copyright Jessica Snyder Sachs, as first appeared in HEALTH magazine
Three months before she gave birth last year, Diana Simpson, a
dental hygienist in Davison, Michigan, started coughing uncontrollably.
The pain in her throat and chest was unbearable. "It brought me to
tears," she remembers. Simpson's family doctor tested her for asthma,
but she didn't have asthma. She had pertussis, a bacterial infection
that usually goes by the name whooping cough because of its distinctive seal-like cough.Most people are vaccinated against pertussis as kids. But here's a surprise: It's come roaring back since an all-time low in the 1970s, largely due to waning immunity in adults who received shots in early childhood. The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) now recommends that all adults get a pertussis booster shot to strengthen their immunity, yet only 2 percent of adults have had their shots updated. Experts say that's just one of several vaccines you may need now. Here's the scoop.
Whooping cough
Vaccine: Tdap
The good news: If you get your regular tetanus-diptheria (Td) booster every 10 years, you won't need an extra jab for pertussis. Vaccine makers have added a pertussis component to that booster, so next time you're due for your Td booster request the Tdap. If you've lost track of your vaccines, ask your doc to contact your previous physicians. And there's no harm in getting the Tdap as long as two years have passed since your last Td booster. Better too soon than too late when a pertussis outbreak has hit your community.
Simpson was too late: She had passed the infection to her mother and her baby, too, landing the newborn in the hospital three weeks after he was born. That's when they all were diagnosed and received the antibiotic erythromycin to keep the infection from spreading further, though they all continued coughing for months. If pertussis isn't caught in the first few weeks, the infection may take three months to run its course. The greatest danger is to babies, who almost always catch it from unvaccinated adults. (The number of U.S. pertussis cases now ranks in the thousands each year, with deaths in the double digits, mostly due to related pneumonia.)
Simpson and her baby, along with her mother (and husband, too), eventually got the shot for future protection.
Chicken pox
Vaccine: Varivax
More than 90 percent of women in their childbearing years are immune to chicken pox because they had it as kids. The rest should be vaccinated before they try to get pregnant because catching the illness during pregnancy can lead to devastating birth defects. Once you get the vaccine (which was introduced in 1995), the CDC says you should delay trying to conceive for at least one month, due to the small risk that the fetus can get the virus from the vaccine. Chicken pox complications are much more frequent and severe in adults than children and can include life-threatening pneumonia and encephalitis (brain inflammation). And people who've had it are also at risk for shingles. Most insurers cover the chicken pox vaccine for adults.
Shingles
Vaccine: Zostavax
If you've had chicken pox, you have a significant risk of developing shingles, a painful reawakening of the chicken pox virus. Worse, in nearly 50 percent of cases in adults in their 50s, shingles progresses to postherpetic neuralgia, an often agonizing form of nerve damage that can linger for years. (The risk increases with age.) But with the recent Food and Drug Administration (FDA) approval of the Zostavax vaccine, you can lower your risks dramatically. In a study of more than 38,000 adults over age 60, the vaccine cut the rate of shingles by over half and reduced the incidence of postherpetic neuralgia by two-thirds.
The vaccine was studied in and approved for people over the age of 60 because they have the highest rates of shingles, says William Schaffner, MD, head of preventive medicine at Vanderbilt University Medical Center. "The rates take off at age 50 and become more steep with each decade," he says. But around half of all shingles cases occur in younger adults.
Insurers won't currently pay for vaccination in people under 60, but that may change because studies in 50-and-overs are ongoing. Younger adults can pay out of pocket for this $150 to $200 shot. (Ask your doctor.) Researchers don't yet know whether the vaccine's protection will prove lifelong, though, so you may need a booster when you get older.
The mumps
Vaccine: MMR booster
The measles-mumps-rubella (MMR) vaccine, a must for kids, is back in the adult-vaccine lineup, too. "Mumps is the problem," reports CDC epidemiologist Andrew Kroger, MD. The number of Americans who caught this viral disease jumped to 6,584 in 2006 from 300 or less in most years. A large mumps outbreak in the Midwest was responsible for most of these cases, and outbreaks continue in Canada and neighboring states such as Maine. The problem may be a spillover from countries like the United Kingdom and Japan, where lagging childhood immunization rates spurred a comeback.
Mumps can be painful and sometimes dangerous. There's the textbook swelling of salivary glands around the neck, but some women also suffer from inflammation of the ovaries. In rare instances, mumps can trigger life-threatening encephalitis.
The CDC encourages all adults to check their status: Do you know whether you were immunized or had the disease as a child? Those born before 1957 are presumed to have been infected or exposed, which provides lifelong immunity. The spottiest protection is among those born between 1957 and 1967, who are less likely to have had mumps or who may have received a less-effective vaccine. A single dose of the current MMR should bring your protection up to date, Kroger says, and it may be covered by your insurance.
Travel Vaccines
Going on a cruise or an organized tour? Consider getting a flu shot,
says Schaffner, who reports that influenza outbreaks frequently occur
on cruise ships, even during summer voyages to northern destinations
like Alaska. "Whenever people are jammed together, influenza is a
risk," he explains.
In addition, visitors to Asia should talk to their doctors about vaccine protection against typhoid and Japanese encephalitis. Visitors to the "meningitis belt" of central Africa should get a meningococcal vaccine. And yellow fever vaccines are important for travelers to much of South America and parts of Africa.
Hepatitis B
Vaccine: Recombivax HB or Engerix-B
Both vaccines protect against the hepatitis B virus, which is spread through sexual contact or contaminated needles and blood. An infection can lead to dangerous liver disease. Each year, more than 78,000 Americans become infected and about 5,000 die of associated liver diseases, including cancer, yet few know that the CDC recommends the vaccine for all sexually active people who are not in long-term relationships.
Flu
Vaccine: Influenza shot or FluMist nasal vaccine
A dangerous bug known as methicillin-resistant Staph. aureus (MRSA) may aggressively attack flu-weakened lungs, according to William Schaffner, MD, head of preventive medicine at Vanderbilt University Medical Center. MRSA was previously confined to hospitals but is spreading into communities nationwide. The link is unclear, but there may be a connection in the way that flu weakens the immune system and MRSA attacks it. MRSA is often marked by nasty skin infections. The strains contracted outside the hospital are now associated with some 13,500 deaths in the United States each year, many involving flu sufferers. "If you need further motivation to get a flu shot," Schaffner says, "there it is."
Jessica Snyder Sachs is the author of Good Germs, Bad Germs, out in paperback this fall.
illustration by Gary Taxali
As first appeared in The New York Times, Op-Ed page, 10 Oct 2007
Copyright JESSICA SNYDER SACHS
IT'S flu season, and health agencies have expanded their flu shot recommendations to include all children ages 6 months to 5 years in addition to adults over age 50, and anyone, child or adult, with a chronic condition like severe allergies, asthma or diabetes.
More parents than ever before - nearly 65 percent - intend to vaccinate their young children this year, according to a poll by the University of Michigan. But that leaves more than a third unenthusiastic about doing so. Their reluctance may reflect not only weariness with the increasing number of childhood immunizations but also the widespread sentiment that colds and flus are a "natural" part of childhood, even vital for toughening up a developing immune system.
Some parents have come to embrace colds and flus, and in recent years we've seen a resurgence of the chickenpox party, where parents deliberately expose their preschoolers to infected playmates on the theory that it's better to get the disease than to have the vaccine.
But the idea that illness is good for children - or anyone else - is wrong. In part, the idea of "good sickness" is a throwback to a now disproved version of the "hygiene hypothesis."
In 1989, an epidemiologist in Britain, David Strachan, observed that babies born into households with lots of siblings were less likely than other babies to develop allergies and asthma. The same proved true of babies who spent significant time in day care. Dr. Strachan hypothesized that the protection came from experiencing an abundance of childhood illnesses.
Dr. Strachan's original hygiene hypothesis got a lot of press, not only in the news media but in serious medical journals. Less publicized was the decade-long string of follow-up studies that disproved a link between illnesses and protection from inflammatory disorders like allergies and asthma. If anything, studies showed, early illness made matters worse.
Moreover, studies now show that the more infections a person has during childhood, the greater his or her chance of premature death from scourges of old age like heart disease and cancer. The link appears to be chronic inflammation, a kind of lingering collateral damage from the body's disease-fighting response.
Still, Dr. Strachan's original observation was confirmed - as a group, babies in large families and day care are less likely to develop allergies and asthma than are children born into smaller families and kept at home. The same protective effect can be seen in children born on farms and in areas without public sanitation.
But the link isn't disease-causing germs. It's early and ample exposure to harmless bacteria - especially the kinds encountered living close to the land and around livestock and other young children. In other words, dirt, dung and diapers. Just as disease-causing microbes clearly bring on inflammation, harmless microorganisms appear to exert a calming effect on the immune system.
A second misconception common among vaccine-shunning parents is that there's something "natural" about the 6 to 10 respiratory infections the typical American child gets every year (or even the two to four we adults experience). Common, yes; natural no, not if "natural" represents the forces that shaped the human immune system during all but the last sliver of our 250,000 years as Homo sapiens. Colds, flus and most other contagious diseases found a central place in our lives only after we and our domestic animals began crowding together in large settlements some 5,000 years ago.
Yet the most compelling reason to get a flu shot this year is a new and deadly threat - methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus, or MRSA, a dangerous kind of staph that has been causing outbreaks of deadly pneumonia among the otherwise young and healthy, typically on the heels of the flu.
Unfortunately, we have no practical way to eradicate MRSA. About a third of us silently carry staph at any given time, and trying to eradicate MRSA or any other staph strain from a community of symptom-free carriers is difficult to impossible. Worse, the experts conclude, any widespread effort to do so is certain to breed greater drug resistance.
Flu shots don't guarantee protection from MRSA pneumonia. It can piggyback on other kinds of viral respiratory infections. But protecting yourself and your children from the flu may be the best way to reduce your family's risk.
Whether dealing with the flu, other "routine" infections or even the chickenpox, the message is the same: In a world abounding in harmless, even beneficial microbes, don't embrace the tiny fraction that can make you ill.
Jessica Snyder Sachs, the former managing editor of Science Digest, is the author of the forthcoming book "Good Germs, Bad Germs: Health and Survival in a Bacterial World."
By Jessica Snyder Sachs, as originally published in PREVENTION
On a mid-August
morning two summers ago, Debbie Twenge started coughing. Just a cold, thought
the resident of Dundee, OR, now 56. But the body-racking cough got worse--much
worse. Over the next 6 weeks, Twenge had to make two trips to the emergency
room. One particularly frightening evening, her daughter called 911 when
Twenge's throat closed up during a coughing fit. "I thought I was going to
die," she recalls.
By the end of
September, her doctor was suggesting tranquilizers--"as if I was just a
nervous female," Twenge says with outrage. That's when her husband read
about a local outbreak of whooping cough, aka pertussis. A test quickly
revealed she had it, but it took 6 months for her to recover from the lingering
inflammation and injury to her breathing passages.
So it was with
great interest that Twenge recently learned that the CDC now recommends all
adults get a booster shot to protect themselves against this
"childhood" disease. Health officials estimate that the vaccine could
prevent more than 8,000 adult infections and 30 to 40 deaths each year.
"If I had known what pertussis was like, I would have jumped at the chance
to be vaccinated," says Twenge.
Chances are, when
you hit adulthood, you figured that you were pretty much done with vaccines,
except for the occasional flu shot. But it's time to roll up your sleeve.
Experts say the right vaccines can prevent pain and misery--and could even save
your life.
Still hesitant?
Worried about side effects? Don't be. Here's the lowdown on the shots you need
and when--and why you want them.
Get It Now
Tdap booster:
Prevents whooping cough, diphtheria, and tetanus
You probably got
a pertussis shot as a child, or maybe even had a bout of whooping cough, and
think you're immune. But experts now realize that neither immunization nor
infection provides lifelong protection. In fact, immunity wanes within 10
years, explains Anne Schuchat, MD, director of the CDC's National Immunization
Program. That's a big reason there's been a massive resurgence of pertussis
over the past 20 years--more than 25,500 cases in the United States in 2005.
Protect yourself:
The next time you're due for your 10-year tetanus-diphtheria shot (Td)--and
yes, you should be getting a tetanus booster every decade--ask for the Tdap
booster, which includes protection against pertussis. Get the shot now if
you're in close contact with a baby or someone whose immune system has been
weakened by age, chemotherapy, or HIV infection--they might not survive if you
pass pertussis to them. (You can get a Tdap booster as soon as 2 years after a
previous Td vaccine.)
MMR: Prevents
mumps, measles, and rubella Just when we'd almost vanquished mumps, the viral
infection is making a comeback. In a typical year, fewer than 300 Americans
catch mumps, but in 2006, there were more than 5,800 cases! The reason may be
found in England: Lagging childhood immunization rates there have led to a
comeback of this disease, and tourists may have carried it here. In adults,
mumps can be serious: 1 in 20 women develops swelling of the ovaries; 1 in 5
men, inflammation of the testes. Rarely, adult mumps can cause potentially
deadly encephalitis (an infection of the brain).
If you were born
between 1957 and 1967, you're particularly susceptible to catching mumps,
because the version of the vaccine your pediatrician gave you wasn't effective
enough to provide reliable lifelong protection.
Protect yourself:
If you're not sure you had mumps or received two MMR doses after 1967, get this
vaccine ASAP. (Kids need two shots 28 days apart; as an adult, you'll get only
one.)
Flu Shots:
Prevents influenza--and reduces risk of potentially deadly pneumonia. Late in 2003 and into 2004,
doctors in the Baltimore area were helpless to save a previously healthy man in
his 50s when he developed an antibiotic-resistant form of pneumonia on the
heels of the flu. Three others--women in their 20s and 30s--nearly died the
same way.
The bug behind
those drug-resistant pneumonias is a new and nasty strain of Staphylococcus
aureus, or MRSA--and researchers say flu raises the risk of catching it. There
are plenty of other reasons to avoid the flu: 36,000 people die each year from
flu-related complications. That's why the CDC now says that all adults should
get an annual flu shot.
Protect yourself:
This fall, get a flu shot or a spritz of the new nasal vaccine, FluMist
(approved for adults up to age 50). It's best to get immunized in October or
November, but immunization as late as January is still worthwhile--the flu
often peaks as late as March.
Get It if You've Had Chickenpox
Zostavax:
Prevents shingles and postherpetic neuralgia
One in four
people who have had chickenpox eventually develops the blistering rash of
shingles--caused when the chickenpox virus, Varicella zoster, is reactivated.
Around 40% will go on to suffer what's been described as the worst kind of pain
imaginable. Called postherpetic neuralgia (PHN), it is so agonizing that it's
been known to lead some people to suicide.
Protect yourself:
As soon as you hit 60, get a dose of Zostavax, approved by the FDA last year.
Schuchat predicts that people in their 50s will eventually be urged to get the
vaccine, too, if ongoing tests show that it's equally effective in their age
group. You've never had chickenpox? Then definitely get the chickenpox vaccine,
Varivax, as well. Adult chickenpox has a substantially higher risk of
complications, such as pneumonia and potentially deadly encephalitis.
Get it if You're
Dating
HPV vaccine
(Gardasil): Prevents cervical cancer
The benefits of
the HPV vaccine for women under 26 have been all over the news. But the
headlines overlooked something important: Gardasil may also be lifesaving for
older women, especially those who are divorced or in a nonmonogamous
relationship. Younger women were studied first because they're more likely to
be exposed to the cancer-causing human papillomavirus, but research is under
way on women over age 26. The vaccine targets four of the viral strains most
commonly associated with cervical cancer and genital warts and, says Schuchat,
"the chance that any woman has been exposed to all four types is tiny. So
the vaccine will probably benefit everyone who gets it."
Protect yourself:
Consider getting the three-shot HPV series if you've been mutually
monogamous--or abstinent--but are now dating again. (Think about getting a
hepatitis B vaccine, too; that sexually transmitted virus sometimes causes
liver cancer.) If you're over age 26, your insurance may not cover the $350
cost of the series, at least until Gardasil is approved for older women or a
similar shot, called Cervarix, gets okayed (that vaccine was recently
green-lighted in Australia for women up to age 45). However, one or both
approvals may happen soon.
Vaccine Fears and
Facts
Fear: Mercury
Fact: A few years
back, researchers raised the concern that people (especially babies) might
accumulate a toxic dose of mercury from thimerosal, a vaccine preservative that
consists largely of the metal. To be on the safe side, thimerosal was removed
from many pediatric vaccines. But since then, studies have shown that the form
of mercury found in the preservative, ethyl mercury, does not build up in the
body.
Fear: Allergic reaction
Fact: These do occur, so tell your doctor if
you have an allergy to egg (flu vaccine), gelatin (MMR vaccine), or yeast (HPV
and hepatitis B vaccines). If you have an unexpected reaction, the doctor will
give you an antihistamine, or a shot of epinephrine if your allergy is severe.
It's worth noting, though, that vaccines cause only one death or serious
reaction per million shots given--and save many more lives by preventing
disease.
Fear: The flu vaccine actually causes the flu
Fact: The flu shot contains no live virus,
while FluMist contains one that has been weakened so that it's incapable of
causing infection. Neither can give you the flu, says Andrew Kroger, MD, a CDC
epidemiologist and vaccine information specialist. But if you were exposed to
the flu right before you were immunized, the protection may come too late to
keep you from getting sick.
Copyright 2007, Prevention
Science writer Jessica Snyder Sachs is the author of Good Germs, Bad Germs: Health and Survival in a Bacterial World (Hill & Wang/FSG).